Blend product, go to market, finance, and people leadership perspectives. Include operators from adjacent models and different growth phases so lessons travel. Prioritize members who prepare rigorously and speak plainly. The goal is constructive friction, not harmony, enabling sharper problem framing, more creative options, and decisions that survive contact with unforgiving market realities.
Run trial sessions, reference checks, and scenario prompts that reveal decision styles under time pressure. Look for curiosity, brevity, humility, and a bias toward action. Define clear expectations around attendance, preparation, and confidentiality. A careful intake process prevents energy leaks later and ensures every voice contributes meaningful perspective rather than performative commentary.
Agree on confidentiality, candor, and the primacy of founder outcomes over debate points. Use time discipline, hand signals, and rotating facilitation to avoid dominance spirals. Normalize saying I do not know and ask for experiments instead of opinions. Strong norms convert diverse personalities into a cohesive engine for decisive learning and sustained momentum.